Official MP3 Release Rules 3.1 _______________________________________________________________ 1. No Dupes ! Complete albums/releases are checked, not single tracks. So a release is not a dupe if it has different or more tracks. Exceptions: 1. It's also a dupe if the complete release is included in a previous one. For example CDM is released, now someone releases the CDS and all tracks of the CDS were already included on the CDM (exactly the same tracks). 2. You are allowed to create a duplicate release from a release that has a source of lower quality (a different source!). Example: if vinyl is out then a CD-release is allowed. If you do that then please add this info to NFO and dirname. For online bought MP3s (-WEB-) we assume the best source quality (CDDA or better). 3. All MIXED cds should be ripped as one track supplied with a .cue. If they are not, they may be duped by another group that releases it as one track with a .cue supplied. 4. It is allowed to release a physical medium version after a WEB or FLASH version. Note that this includes physical medium releases even when they are also available to download for free online. Proofing rule (see section 19) always applies to physical medium. 5. If an unmixed version of a release is available in webshops, it is allowed for both mixed physical and unmixed WEB versions to be released. For all LIVE sources: + If a show has already been released (e.g. another name, but the mix is the same), no dupe of that same show is allowed. If the show is included in another release (for example, as a guest mix), then it is not allowed either. + If a show, containing a guest mix, is a partial dupe (either the regular part of the show, or the guest mix), it is allowed to release them both as a set. However, it is encouraged to release only the new part if the other part is available in equal or better quality, denoting in the nfo why the other part was omitted. + If a show contains the broadcast of a commercially released CD, it may not be released if the CD has already been released. Note: if you want to release an import-album or some "extended edition" then check rule 7 as well ! 2. An SFV and NFO file must be included in every release. All releases from a physical medium must also include a JPG proof - see rule 19. CUE, M3U and additional JPG files (scans) are optional. If you release a CUE file for multitrack mp3s then the CUE file must include artist and tracknames if they are available on the cover or inlay. If you want to release additional material (Videos, Lyrics, ...) from the source medium then you must release that separately with dirname tag -EXTRAS-. 3. Directoryname must at least contain: 1. Artist Name - Title - Published Year (decimal) - Group name (extra info is allowed of course) 2. All bootleg releases must have the word BOOTLEG in dirname. (check bootleg rule 14) 3. If you release magazine CDs then you must tag them as -MAG-. Don't tag them -PROMO-, -ADVANCE- etc.. 4. The directory name of an INTERNAL release must end with _INT. Example: Someone_Something-2007-GROUP_INT 5. For all LIVE sources: It is not necessary to include the name of the station the show is broadcasted on (if it is not included in the directory name, it is strongly encouraged to include it in the nfo instead). The date must be the date of the broadcast. Both USA (-MM/DD-) and EU (-DD/MM-) date format are allowed. Exception: If a vinyl/cd has no title then it's allowed to replace the title by labelname+catnumber (both!). If there is only one artist on the vinyl/cd then you must add the artistname. 4. Filename must at least contain: Track Number - Song Title If it's an album with different artists (one artist per track) then you must add the artist name as well ("VA-tracks" like mixes don't need artistnames). The song title for the filename must include the full title as it's written on the cover/cd/inlay with all additional infos like remixed/featured stuff as long as it doesn't exceed the 128 char limit. Make sure that your filename is unique otherwise some sites might dupeskip. Exception: If no tracknames are supplied by the source (cd,vinyl,..) then you *must* provide proof that these tracks have no names. Either by a scan of the original cover of the record company/label (no selfmade cdr or bootleg covers) or a link to an official or trusted webpage with proofs. If these "untitled tracks" are part of a big mix (no silence between the "tracks") then it's considered as one track and you must rip it as one mp3/cue and give this track same name as the "album". 5. Files/directories must only contain characters a-z A-Z 0-9 _ . - () This is to avoid problems with windows/linux-filesystem and ftp-servers. 6. Self-made releases 1. Self-made compilations are not allowed ! A self-made compilation is when you select tracks from other sources, put them together and release that as something new. 2. A self-made MIX or completely self-made music is not allowed either. If you are releasing self-made stuff then that must be tagged as internal. 7. Bonus tracks 1. The entire CD,Vinyl,etc. must be released (not individual tracks). This means that even if there is one additional (bonus) or otherwise different track on another version of the release, you must still release the whole album/release╖ Note that timing differences of silence at the beginning and/or the end of a track does not render it a different track and a new release is not allowed. 2. It is NOT allowed to re-release a new edition of a retail album if the different/extra/bonus tracks are already included in one previous release. For example, USA album is released and four months later Japanese version is released containing simply a remix from an old CDM/CDS release as a bonus track, it would not be considered new material and then would not be allowed to release as a complete release. Note this does not apply to tracks from an old compilation of Various Artists. 3. For additional tracks in digital download sources, the -BONUS_TRACKS- tag must be used. This is valid either if complete release exist at online source or bonus tracks only. 4. For DVD(A) releases check Rule 10. 8. Current maximum directory/filename-length is 128 characters Exception: Dirfixes that reach the limit by adding "-DIRFIX-" 9. No fake-releases It's a fake release when artist, title, group or source is incorrect (different). examples: - Some_Artist-Crappy_Music-2004-GRP not released by GRP - Another_Artist-Lots_of_Noise-CDM-2004-GRP was ripped from TV or downloaded from a paysite - Madonna-Something_New-2004-GRP really containing some tracks by Marilyn Manson 10. DVD/DVDA Ripping A DVD/DVDA release must contain all music tracks. Additional tracks (interviews etc.) are optional. If those extra tracks are not included then a proper (with ALL tracks) or an additional release (extra tracks only) is not allowed. If tracks are available in several audio formats then you must use the "best" version. Priority is: - PCM stereo (doesn't matter if DVDA or CDDA quality) - PCM 3+ channels - AC3 (dolby digital) stereo or DTS stereo - AC3 (dolby digital) 3+ channels or DTS 3+ channels - MPG Examples: - DVD contains AC3 5.1 and AC3 2.0 => you must rip the AC3 2.0 tracks - DVD contains PCM and AC3 2.0 => you must rip the PCM tracks - DVD contains MPG and AC3 2.0 => you must rip the AC3 2.0 version Normalizing the sound volume is allowed but optional. 11. Encoding Quality 1. For releases made from MP3s (online bought or from FLASH medium) and which are not SBD: VBR (all combinations, but no maximum bitrate limit) and CBR is allowed. The minimum bitrate for CBR is 192kbit. => You release the MP3 as is. It is NOT allowed to re-encode! If the source is below 192 kbit CBR it's not allowed to release it. Release the MP3 unmodifed as you downloaded/copied it. Only adding/changing ID3 tag is allowed. If you want to release a -WEB- mp3 file with constant bitrate (CBR) then you must choose the best version (320->256->224->192 kbit) available at the shop. The same encoder version must be present on every track of a release report to - rule 15. If the FLASH medium contains both WAV and MP3 then you must choose WAV. 2. For ALL sources which need encoding (CD, VINYL, DVD, BLU-RAY, WEB-WAV, SBD, CABLE, LINE, etc.). You must use: LAME 3.98.4 with preset V0 ("-V0"). Additional switches which would affect the mp3 quality are forbidden, especially no minimum or maximum bitrate limits. 3. The sampling rate must be either 44.1khz or 48khz. 32khz is not allowed. Downsampling to 44.1 or 48khz is allowed (if source is better), upsampling to 44.1 or 48khz is not allowed. 4. For all LIVE sources: Straight-to-mp3 encoding is allowed, but discouraged. The header of the mp3 file must be correct at all times. 5. On rare occasion, there may be defects in the actual pressing/mastering/recording/etc in a given audio source (ie. skips, glitches, etc). If these audio defects are identified beforehand in initial nfo or in a later nfofix, then a release cannot be considered invalid until there is a valid one pred. (ie; proper release clean of audio defects)╖ 12. Promos If a release is considered not to have every track from the source then it must be labeled as a promo and can be duped by any legitimate retail release that DOES contain all tracks. The legitimate release can be identified by the CAT number, or more suitable proof. Promos do not have to contain track listings, they are promotional material, they are not considered legitimate releases, and are still governed by quality rules. If you release a promo when the retail is already out then you must provide proof that this promo is real to make sure this is not a selfmade "promo". 13. Re-encodes are not allowed. Exception: releases of following sources are currently allowed if they are tagged correctly: DVD, DAB, DVBC/DVBS/DVBT/SAT (compressed digital tv/radio sat,cable,terrestrial), MD (live) 14. All bootleg releases must have the word BOOTLEG in dirname A bootleg recording is a cd/vinyl/dvd that was not officially released by the person/company owning the rights to do that (for example streetmixes, pirate live cds, etc). Because very often it's not 100% clear if something is bootleg there are conditions when we assume something is or isn't bootleg. This is not a definition of "bootleg" and if a condition is not true then it does not mean the opposite is true. This only helps nukers and groups to decide if a bootleg tag is needed and hopefully leads to more fair nuking. conditions for: [records done completely by the artist] (no samples from other artists) It's bootleg if ... - there are no signs that the label really released this - the "label" has no connection to the artist (independent releases (no label, own label) are allowed and don't need a bootleg tag) even if the conditions above are true it is NOT bootleg if: - the record is available at at least 3 major retail shops conditions for: [mixes] (samples of other artists included) It's not bootleg if ... - the record is available at at least 3 major retail shops - the label exists and lists the record and the label never released any bootlegs and released stuff that was available at major retail shops - the artist or label of the samples confirms this release is valid (on their webpage or some other trusted place) "major retail shops" currently are: www.amazon.com (.de, .fr ...) www.bestbuy.com www.walmart.com www.cduniverse.com www.virginmegastores.co.uk (.gr, .fr, .jp) (US shop excluded) www.sonymusicstore.com www.juno.co.uk www.deejay.de www.ukdancerecords.com www.dancegrooves.com www.decks.de www.4djsonly.com The shop itself must sell the record (no private sellers). 15. SOURCE The tracks of a release must all be from the same source and have the same quality/cbr-bitrate/vbr-setting/encoder/setting (Exception: FLASH releases). Taking tracks from other scene releases or internal group releases of other groups is strictly forbidden. If the source is not a pressed CDDA then the directory name needs a valid source tag. Valid tags are listed below. 1. =RETAIL SOURCES= [CD SINGLE] (pressed CDDA) dirtag needed: -CDS- or -CDM- [CD ALBUM] (pressed CDDA) dirtag needed: none dirtag suggested: -CDA- (-2CDA- -3CDA- etc.) [CD OTHER] (pressed CDDA) dirtag needed: none dirtag suggested: -CD- (-2CD- -3CD- etc.), -CDEP- [VINYL SINGLE] dirtag needed: -VLS- or -VINYL- dirtag suggested: -VLS- [VINYL ALBUM] dirtag needed: -LP- or -VINYL- dirtag suggested: -LP- [VINYL OTHER] dirtag needed: -VINYL- [DVD] (pressed video DVD) dirtag needed: -DVD- (-2DVD- -3DVD- etc.) extra nfo info needed: - codec of source (AC3, PCM, MPG, DTS), - number of channels of source (stereo, 5.1, ...) [DVD SINGLE] (pressed video DVD)] dirtag needed: -DVDS- or -DVD- dirtag suggested: -DVDS- extra nfo info needed: - codec of source (AC3, PCM, MPG, DTS), - number of channels of source (stereo, 5.1, ...) [DVDA] (PCM data of a pressed DVDA, not audio of a video DVD!) dirtag needed: -DVDA- (-2DVDA- -3DVDA- etc.) extra nfo info needed: - number of channels of source (stereo, 5.1, ...) [SACD] dirtag needed: -SACD- (-2SACD- -3SACD- etc.) [HD DVD] (pressed) dirtag needed: -HDDVD- (-2HDDVD- -3HDDVD- etc.) extra nfo info needed: - codec of source (AC3, DD+, PCM, MPG, DTS, DTS-HD, Dolby TrueHD) - bitrate of source (448kbps, 640kbps, 768kbps, 1536kbps...) - number of channels of source (stereo, 5.1, ...) [BLU-RAY DISC] (pressed) dirtag needed: -BD- (-2BD- -3BD- etc.) extra nfo info needed: - codec of source (AC3, DD+, PCM, MPG, DTS, DTS-HD, Dolby TrueHD) - bitrate of source (448kbps, 640kbps, 768kbps, 1536kbps...) - number of channels of source (stereo, 5.1, ...) [FLASH medium] (SlotMusic, CompactStick, ...) dirtag needed: -FLASH- extra nfo info needed: - codec of source (MP3, PCM (WAV), ...) - proof photo of medium+cover 2. =DIGITAL DOWNLOADS= [WEB] - audio files legally available on the net and not free dirtag needed: -WEB- extra nfo info needed: - codec of source (MP3, WAV, AIFF, FLAC, see next NOTE below), - bitrate of source file (if not lossless source), - URL to some shop where it's available in that format [WEB] - audio files available only at services appointed by the label. audio files available only with Digital Download Cards/Code access, email or any other private links. dirtag needed: -WEB- extra nfo info needed: - codec of source (MP3, WAV, AIFF, FLAC, see next NOTE below), - bitrate of source file (if not lossless source), - camera picture required from the physical release that includes the singular digital download - rule 19. NOTE: common lossless compression sources are WAV, PCM, AIFF, FLAC, ALAC, APE. Lossless means that the de-compressed audio is exactly the same bytes as the original. 3. =LIVE SOURCES= [ANALOG RADIO] (terrestrial) dirtag needed: -FM- [ANALOG CABLE] dirtag needed: -CABLE- [ANALOG OR DIGITAL SAT] dirtag needed: -SAT- [DIGITAL VIDEO BROADCAST SAT] dirtag needed: -DVBS- [DIGITAL VIDEO BROADCAST CABLE] dirtag needed: -DVBC- [DIGITAL VIDEO BROADCAST TERRESTRIAL] dirtag needed: -DVBT- [DIGITAL AUDIO BROADCAST] dirtag needed: -DAB- [MD] (MiniDisc) dirtag needed: -MD- [direct live recording from the audience] dirtag needed: -AUD- [direct recording by the ripper from soundboard/mixer through the LINE-in interface] dirtag needed: -LINE- [MP3 FILE supplied by a radio station or DJ] (and not recorded from a webstream) dirtag needed: -SBD- [WEBSTREAM] (not allowed, so must be released internally) dirtag needed: -STREAM- 4. =OTHER SOURCES= [CDR] (small label/artist releasing CDDA on CDR or LIVE set supplied on CDR) dirtag needed: -CDR- (-2CDR- -3CDR- etc.) [DVDR] (small label/artist releasing on DVDR) dirtag needed: -DVDR- (-2DVDR- -3DVDR- etc.) extra nfo info needed: - codec of source (AC3, PCM, MPG, DTS), - number of channels of source (stereo, 5.1, ...) [HD DVD RECORDABLE] dirtag needed: -HDDVDR- (-2HDDVDR- -3HDDVDR- etc.) extra nfo info needed: - codec of source (AC3, DD+, PCM, MPG, DTS, DTS-HD, Dolby TrueHD) - bitrate of source (448kbps, 640kbps, 768kbps, 1536kbps...) - number of channels of source (stereo, 5.1, ...) [BLU-RAY DISC RECORDABLE] dirtag needed: -BDR- (-2BDR- -3BDR- etc.) extra nfo info needed: - codec of source (AC3, DD+, PCM, MPG, DTS, DTS-HD, Dolby TrueHD) - bitrate of source (448kbps, 640kbps, 768kbps, 1536kbps...) - number of channels of source (stereo, 5.1, ...) [DAT TAPE] dirtag needed: -DAT- [ANALOG TAPE] dirtag needed: -TAPE- [UNKNOWN] dirtag needed: -BOOTLEG- All other "sources" are invalid source tags (-LIVE- , -EP-, ...). Which means you need a second tag for the source if you use those tags (except for CDs which don't need a source tag). A SBD release is not allowed if it could be a re-encode/repack of the same show streamed or downloaded free from inet. If a free broadcast or download is/was available with 160kbit CBR or better then it's not allowed to do a SBD release. 16. Fixes 1. Trackfixes Only one trackfix per release is allowed. If the release needs a second trackfix or more than 50% of the tracks need a fix then you must re-rip the whole release and all previous releases+dir/nfofixes getting nuked. A 1-track fix for a 2-track release is allowed (=50% and not "more than 50%"). 2. Dirname/ID3 Fixes If you release a dirfix then the dirname of the problematic release must be listed in your NFO file. If a release gets nuked for BAD DIRNAME or BAD ID3 then the releasegroup has 72 hours to release a Dir/ID3Fix. If they don't do it within the 72 hours then any other group is allowed to release a fix or re-release. The 72 hours start when the release gets nuked. 3. Prooffixes a) If you fail to add scans/photos you have 24 hours AFTER PRE to release a Prooffix. Before, during and after this 24 hours grace period, any other group is allowed to release a PROPER with scans/photos even if the release is 100% identical. b) If the provided proof was judged inadequate and nuked, you have 24 hours AFTER NUKE to release a prooffix. Before, during and after this 24 hours grace period, any other group is allowed to release a PROPER with scans/photos even if the release is 100% identical. 17. ID3 Tags All mp3 files need an ID3 v1.1 and ID3 v2 tag. This tag must include Artist, Title and Album (see Note #3). The fields Year, Genre and Tracknumber must be present but may not be nuked if incorrect. 18. LIVE release quality 1. The set must be complete. This means that every part of the show must be released, and the beginning and end must be included in their entirety. A set may not miss more than 1 minute from begin or end. 2. All commercials must be edited out. 3. DJ talk can be included to a certain extent: track announcements and short lines from the DJ should not be removed; interviews and other long talk should be removed (or included in a separate file if it's special). 4. It is encouraged to fade-in and fade-out the set. However, lack of fades constitutes no proper reason. 19. Scans/Photos 1. All releases from physical sources must always include proof. 2. Proof means a good quality scan or photo of the physical medium together with the cover or a booklet page so the proof can be identified as the release in question. If the medium or cover/booklet contain anything that may expose your identity, then that part of the image can be blurred or blackened. Additional scans may be added but these DO NOT count as sufficient proof! For bundled versions of two or more sources, it is allowed to use cover and medium of these sources as long as it was distributed as a bundle and not separately. (examples: 1 - DVD cover format with CD. 2 - vinyl cover format with CD). For multi-disc sets, all medium of same source must be together with the cover or a booklet page so the proof can be identified as the release in question. Make your proof as close as possible to the included examples. 3. A note with the group name on the proof is optional except for releases without cover - rule 19.6. 4. Proof resolution must be 640x480 pixels or higher in standard JPEG format. 5. We STRONGLY recommend the removal of all Exif data! Uniquely identifying information such as the camera serial number and GPS coordinates can pose a security threat if not removed. Use tools such as jhead, PureJPG or the inbuilt function of Win7/Vista to remove the Exif data. 6. Whitelabel, test presses and promo releases officialy distributed without cover/case/artwork cover requires note with group name over the medium. 20. FLASH medium ripping 1. A FLASH release must contain all music tracks. For additional stuff (videos, pictures etc.) see rule 2. 2. If the FLASH medium contains WAV files you must encode them with scene standards. 3. If the FLASH medium contains multiple formats (e.g. 10 tracks WAV and a DJ MIX MP3) it is allowed to release it with mixed VBR/CBR and multiple encoders. 21. High Definition Ripping 1. A HD DVD/BLU-RAY release must contain complete music track from concert. Additional tracks (interviews, videos, bonus etc.) are optional. If those extra tracks are not included then a proper (with ALL tracks) or an additional release (extra tracks only) is not allowed. 2. HD DVD and BLU-RAY video clip releases should be ripped as multi track release keeping original tracklist (not .m2ts sequence). 3. If tracks are available in several audio formats then you must use the highest bitrate lossless source track. DTS core must be extracted from a DTS HR/HD MA track (if that is the source in use). 4. Multi channel audio is not allowed. Downmix source track to stereo 2 channels. 5. Downsampling to 44.1 or 48khz is allowed (if source is better), upsampling to 44.1 or 48khz is not allowed. 6. Normalizing the sound volume is allowed but optional. 7. CUE file made from source chapters should always be include with final release package. 8. HD DVD, BLU-RAY, DVD and DVDA sources dupe each other. 9. HD DVD/BLU-RAY release are NOT allowed if retail CD version with same tracks has been released already. Notes: 1. Releases with an apparently incorrect year may not be nuked. However the year should be correct of course. Keep in mind that a lot of sites nuke for fake year when it's incorrect. (The Year in dirname is not the year when you released it but when the record company/artist published it!) 2. If a release labeled as "advance" is identical to the retail version then the advance turns into a retail release. This means then it is not allowed to dupe it and it counts as retail for ALL rules. If the retail is different then of course it's allowed to release it. 3. Typos (in dirname, trackname, id3, etc ...) are tolerated if it still is readable and either artist or title is 100% correct. 4. The audio of a normal video DVD is *NOT* DVDA ! The audio of a DVD usually is MP2/AC3/DTS compressed (lossy) while the audio of a real DVDA is high quality PCM (lossless, e.g. 24bit/192khz). Tagging a normal DVD release as -DVDA- will get nuked. change-log: 2007-01-15 first version (v1.0) 2007-06-01 rule 1: live sources addition 2007-06-01 1.4 added (CD after WEB allowed) 2007-06-01 3.4 added (INT tagging) 2007-06-01 3.5 added (live sources) 2007-06-01 rule 4 addition (remix info in filenames) 2007-06-01 rule 7 reworded to make clear it's for promos/advances too and to allow full re-releases within 3 months more than 30% is new. 2007-06-01 rule 11 addition: best CBR must be released for WEB releases 2007-06-01 11.3 added (minimum sampling rate) 2007-06-01 11.4 added + rewordings for live sources 2007-06-01 rule 13 adjusted for live sources 2007-06-01 rule 15 reworded to forbid different encoders in one release 2007-06-01 rule 15 new sources HD DVD and BLU RAY added 2007-06-01 rule 15 "CDDA" added to all CD-sources 2007-06-01 rule 15 all live sources adjusted, "SBD" rips limited 2007-06-01 rule 18 added (LIVE release quality) 2009-09-01 rule 1.4 CD after FLASH allowed 2009-09-01 rule 2 addition (additional material must be released separately with tag -EXTRAS-) 2009-09-01 rule 6.2 reworded to forbid homemade releases 2009-09-01 rule 11 lame 3.90.3 removed 2009-09-01 rule 12 last paragraph moved to rule 20 2009-09-01 rule 15 (FREE MP3s) addition (physical retail release allowed even if free version available) (rule removed on 2011-04-15) 2009-09-01 rule 15 source AUD re-added and HOMEMADE source removed 2009-09-01 16.2 added (Dirname/ID3 Fixes) 2009-09-01 rule 17 addition (ID3 v2) 2009-09-01 19 added (Scans/Photos) 2009-09-01 20 added (FLASH medium ripping) 2011-04-15 15 removed because it was obsolete + renumbered the following rules 2011-04-15 rule 2 reworded to include .JPG files 2011-04-15 rule 11.2 reworded to make it more clear + lame version updated to 3.98.4 and V0 2011-04-15 rule 15 addition (needed extra NFO info for HD releases) 2011-04-15 rule 16.3 added (Prooffixes) 2011-04-15 rule 19 (Scans/Photos) completely redone (All releases from physical sources must always include proof.) 2011-04-15 21 added (High Definition ripping) 2014-01-15 rule 1.4 physical medium sources after digital downloads releases. 2014-01-15 rule 1.5 Cleared out what happens with mixed/unmixed CD vs WEB. 2014-01-15 rule 7 New title + renumbered. 2014-01-15 rule 7.1 complete releases allowed 2014-01-15 rule 7.3 digital download -BONUS_TRACKS- releases. 2014-01-15 rule 11.1 same encoder for digital downloads. 2014-01-15 rule 11.5 added. 2014-01-15 rule 15 renumbered + additional web sources. 2014-01-15 rule 16.3 b) added. 2014-01-15 rule 19.2 adjusted for multiple source in same release and multi-disc releases. 2014-01-15 rule 19.3 adjusted for releases without cover. 2014-01-15 rule 19.6 added. V3.1 active since 2014-01-15, signed by: 1REAL 211 AMOK AMRC BCC BERC BFHMP3 BriBerY CHN CMS DEF dL DLiTE EMP FALCON FiH FWYH gEm gnvr GRAVEWISH H3X H5N1 hM hXc iHF KALEVALA KLV jAZzMan MTD MYCEL NSTM pLAN9 PMS PsyCZ QMI r35 RTB SHELTER SNOOK SnS sour TR UPE WAV WHOA